I’m undertaking a 1000-day reinvention project, blogging here daily to track my progress. In Monday Money, I write about money management.
My father manages a trust account from my aunt, who passed away a few years ago. The investments in the trust have been managed by professionals for years, and have done incredibly well because of a heavy concentration in AI-related individual stocks. Currently the investments are invested approximately 70% in stocks and 30% in bonds.
I spoke with the asset manager for the trust last week and he proposed gradually moving to a 60/40 allocation, which seemed reasonable to me on first thought. With bond yields having risen substantially recently (meaning bond prices have gone down), some financial pundits say it’s time to add more bonds to your portfolio. According to CNBC, Bank of America’s Michael Hartnett declared in a client note titled “The Price is Right” that now may be a good entry point for bonds, saying that the “secular contrarian [trade] would be adding bonds.”
I have been skeptical of bonds for a while and my father’s asset manager knows it, as I used to use him for my retirement assets, and I kept telling him “no more bonds!” when he wanted to add more over the past year or so. I was proven right, but I don’t in general believe I can predict market outcomes.
In The 60/40 Portfolio Is Caught in an Inflation Trap on Bloomberg, Simon White writes “when 10-year yields remain above 5.25%-5.50%, the correlation between stocks and Treasuries has almost always been positive.” That means that bonds do not serve as an equity hedge in such cases, because a positive correlation between the two asset classes means that as one goes down (for example, stocks decline) so will the other (bonds). We saw that in 2022, as the Fed hiked interest rates.
Why might it be that higher yields are associated with a positive stock-bond correlation? Because of inflation, writes White:
With inflation, as with yields, a bifurcated relationship in the stock-bond correlation can also be seen, with the stock-bond correlation having almost always been positive when core PCE is above 3%.
Three percent inflation has “historically been the level when non-linear shifts in inflation occur.” At these levels, you don’t see stationary, stable inflation. Participants in an economy with recent experience of high inflation are more likely to continue to expect high inflation, and shocks accumulate, says White.
In The Major bond letter #29: The penultimate hike from January 30, 2023, Steven Major (then HSBC’s global head of fixed income research) writes “Historical data for US bond market returns tells us that the best time to buy bonds is on the penultimate hike.”
But you don’t know in advance which is the next-to-the-last hike of course.
Based on current forecasts, we could be looking at one or two more quarter-point hikes. Most market participants expect an October hawkish hold (meaning the Fed will talk of upcoming rate hikes but not raise them anymore at this upcoming meeting) with an 80% probability of at least a quarter-point increase by December and possibly one more hike after that.
I expect we haven’t seen the penultimate hike yet, but December may bring it. Hot inflation prints into December will mean the Fed does hike at the last meeting of the year. In 2027, the first two meetings are January and March, with no meeting in February. I could imagine that there may be a hike in December, another hike in January, and then weakening financial conditions leading to an end to the rate hiking cycle.
It’s probably not a terrible time to gradually reduce stock exposure in favor of bonds. However, we could see ongoing inflation spikes and surges, as White suggests.
In my own retirement portfolio, I won’t add bond exposure until the ETFs I use cross above their 200-day moving average.
How would this compare to using the penultimate rate hike, in a past rate hiking cycle? Let’s look at 2022 into 2023, when the Fed hiked rates 11 times by a 525 basis points to combat post-pandemic inflation. The next-to-last (penultimate) rate hike was May 3, 2023, and the last arrived in July of 2023.
In the chart below, with the blue line showing the 200-day simple moving average, you can see that getting in at the May rate hike actually would still see you suffer losses of around 20% before the price starting increasing again.
With a rule of getting in and out via the 200-day moving average, you would have been out during 2022, and then briefly in around the time of the penultimate rate hike, and out again until the end of the year.

Since then, TLT has been above and below the 200-day but not really in a durable bull market.
I’m 50/50 on adding bonds here. I lean towards a continued bond bear market playing out, with inflation proving sticky and showing surges. But I know I can’t predict what’s going to happen, and another thing that might play out is weakening growth, decreased inflation, and a flight from risk assets into what appears safer (Treasuries, not always so safe).