I’m undertaking a 1000-day reinvention project, blogging here daily to track my progress. In Tuesday Book Club, I share an idea from a book.

Yesterday afternoon I attended the closing of the (Un)Altered Books: Unheard Voices show sponsored by the Women’s Caucus for Art Colorado Chapter, the University of Denver Libraries, and the Blair Caldwell Library. About 30 women showed up to talk about their book-based art. I shared a little about the book assemblage I had in the show.
I felt incredibly self-conscious and afterward, concluded I hadn’t done a good job communicating about my artwork.
Today I want to write about various forms of consciousness: self-consciousness of the type I felt last night, co-consciousness as formulated by developmental psychologist Rochat, and I-consciousness as a way of elaborating on Nietzsche’s idea of individual drive. And I will bring in ideas from American pragmatist George Herbert Mead to bridge the Nietzschean and Rochatean views.
Nietzsche and Rochat on consciousness
In The Gay Science, 19th century German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche lays out an argument for the origins of human consciousness. He writes that early humans were endangered by predators and, in order to survive, needed protection from other humans and needed to be able to coordinate plans together. To do this, humans had to evaluate what they lacked and how they felt, then translate this inner states into language or other signs that other humans could understand. Nietzsche concludes that “consciousness has developed only under the pressure of the need for communication.”
Further, Nietzsche argues that because consciousness evolved alongside language to allow individuals to communicate and coordinate, our conscious thoughts are never truly private or unique. We use shared concepts, categories, and grammar — what he calls the perspective of the “herd.”
In Others in Mind: Social Origins of Self-Consciousness, Swiss developmental psychologist Philippe Rochat develops a similar argument. He suggests that human self-consciousness takes the form of what he calls co-consciousness, holding both a first person perspective (how I feel) and a third-person perspective (how I appear to someone else) at the exact same time.
Nietzsche views consciousness as inherently falsifying and superficial, because it must simplify and conceptualize our vast, chaotic, and unique inner drives into a form suited for communication and coordination. For Nietzsche, leaning too heavily on social-consciousness alienates us from our creative individuality.
Rochat, on the other hand, treats this socially-constructed awareness not as a trap or a falsification, but as the foundation of human empathy, morality, and culture. He acknowledges the pain of shame and the fear of ostracism. But he sees co-consciousness as a mechanism that allows us to build trust, cooperative, and form meaningful human bonds.
For both, the identity of the self to the extent it is defined by our consciousness is created via the demands of the collective. Rochat, however, sees it as the birth of our intrinsic humanity. Nietzsche sees it as the driver of our conformity.
Bridging the Nietzschean and the Rochatean view of the self-conscious self
American philosopher and social theorist George Herbert Mead (1863–1931), a significant figure in classical American pragmatism, provides an account that can bridge these two kinds of selves: the socially-aware and conformist Rochatean version and the potentially culturally oppressed individual creative Nietzschean self seeking outlet.
Mead distinguishes between the “I” and the “Me,” functionally distinct versions of the self (not metaphysically distinct). “Me” is that self that arises in relationship to the generalized other, that other defined by whatever situation we find ourselves in. For example, last night I went to the closing of an art show. I shared about my art, as did the other artists there. The “Me” that was thinking about what other people might want to hear about my art was considering the “generalized other” as the other artists who were in attendance. This is the Rochatean self.
On the other hand, there is the “I” who is the creative Nietzschean individual. The “I” acts out of creativity, freedom, and personality. The “I” was at the art show closing too, deciding what to say and how to act not based on social demands but based on spontaneity and personal expressiveness.
To Mead, the actions of the “I” are non-reflective and arise without our awareness. Once they have become objectified and known, then that is the “Me.” Similarly, Nietzsche thinks that our consciousness is based on social construction. Does that mean there is no interior, unique, individually creative consciousness to Mead or Nietzsche?
Different forms of consciousness
When I make art, it often arises not conceptually or consciously, but as via a channel, via what some writers about creativity call a daemon, a supernatural entity or guardian spirit that dwells between the divine and the mortal. It is not a conscious process although I become conscious of the artwork’s meaning and beauty as it emerges.
This is something like the “I” of Mead, and the authentic, creative individual of Nietzsche. Mead and Nietzsche think of these instantiations of the self in somewhat different ways. But they both recognize that there is a pre-reflective consciousness at work (to use a term from Sartre).1
Then there is self-consciousness — the “me” of Mead, my awareness of who I should be and am based on a specific generalized social other. I say “specific” to refer to a particular context, such as an art show closing, a work setting, a Thanksgiving dinner.
Is that self-consciousness the same as Rochat’s co-consciousness? That term makes me think of something somewhat different: perhaps a person acting as part of a collective without having a particular awareness of themselves as an “I” or as an ego but acting collaboratively and cooperatively while the self fades to the background.
Making Thanksgiving dinner, at its best, involves co-consciousness, family members and friends working together to prepare and serve a feast, celebrating their gratefulness for one another and for the blessings of their lives. Even when I’ve lit a turkey on fire trying to grill it, I didn’t feel pangs of self-consciousness. My ego was small and quiet.
I’m thinking of three kinds of consciousness:
- Pre-reflective consciousness or maybe let’s call it Ego-Less-Consciousness or No-one-consciousness: the consciousness of creative channeling. Mead’s “I” in action. The Nietzschean self becoming.
- Self-consiousness or Ego-Consciousness: when I am at once overly aware of myself but also aware of the social setting’s demands. Nietzschean falsifying and superficial consciousness (sort of).
- Co-consciousness: the ego dissolves, but an awareness of being one in a community remains. Rochatean consciousness.
I think there may be yet a fourth kind of consciousness: a recognition of a unique Nietzschean individual out in the wild, detected via their creative output. Let’s call it alter-consciousness for now. You are pulled entirely out of yourself in awe of another individual’s unique becoming. Another term might be thou-consciousness, seeing another person as a whole being, a true self not an It or an object. This kind of consciousness is ego-free, just like Ego-Less-Consciousness (which needs a better name).
A Four-Mode Map of Artistic Consciousness & Activity
Gemini helped me pull this together.
| Mode | Term | Direction of Awareness | What It Feels Like |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Making | Pre-Reflective / Flow Consciousness | Outward into the medium (Ego absent) | Channeling unconscious or universal forces without self-interference. |
| 2. Presenting | Self-Consciousness | Inward on the ego (Ego trapped) | Hyper-aware of scrutiny; feeling exposed, isolated, and evaluated. |
| 3. Belonging | Co-Consciousness | Reciprocal between self & group (Ego balanced) | Grounded in community with fellow artists; mutual respect and dialogue. |
| 4. Witnessing | Other- (or I-Thou) Consciousness | Outward toward another’s genius (Ego transcended) | Stunned by the unique, irreducible becoming of another person’s soul in their work. |
The problem I’m facing is that I experience group show artist talks as purely operating in Mode 2 and Mode 3. But as an artist, I seek Modes 1 and 4.
And here’s ChatGPT’s formulation of the four modes.

I’m not sure which formulation I prefer, but either way, I am feeling more clarity on why I find group art shows dissatisfying.
- I plan to explore Sartre’s ideas about Le Regard in my Thursday Thinker post this week, where when you are seen by another person you experience yourself as an object within the other’s world. ↩︎