Day 524 of 1000: Complexities of Retirement Money Management

I’m undertaking a 1000-day reinvention project, blogging here daily to track my progress. In Monday Money, I write about money management.

Yesterday I wrote about creating a 20-year retirement financial forecast. Today I want to explore what implications the results have for managing my money.

If you go to a financial advisor, fee-based or percent-of-assets based, they might run a Monte Carlo retirement analysis for you. This runs thousands of individual forecasts with different assumptions about investment returns year-by-year to give you an idea of worst case, best case, and average case outcomes for your money. With such a simulation, you don’t base your understanding and decisions on one straight-line forecast of returns, such as 7%.

Typically such a report will tell you probabilities of running out of money at a certain age or dying with a certain net worth.

I’ve had these run for me numerous times in my life and I haven’t found them very helpful, despite the fact that I am a PhD statistician with extensive training in probability. They try to characterize uncertainty and communicate it, but it doesn’t result in my feeling confidence about what to do.

An important issue that such an analysis can highlight for you is sequence of returns risk (SORR), the risk that in the early years of retirement you may see poor investment returns, leaving you much worse off than if instead you saw high returns early and poor returns later. Your later high investment returns will be compounding on a smaller balance, if there’s a big correction or crash early. This is not just of academic interest right now, as stock markets around the world are wobbling, and some say the AI bubble may be in the process of bursting. Meanwhile, bonds are in an ongoing bear market and the Fed is raising rates. Inflation appears sticky. Even just staying even with your money for the next one to two years looks questionable. If you just hold cash, you’re losing to inflation. If you try for stocks, they might serve you with a big drawdown when you can least afford it. If you go for TIPS (treasury inflation-protected securities) you might buy them right as inflation moderates.

Retirement glide paths

Some financial advisors talk about retirement glide paths, automatic adjustments to your portfolio allocation according to a formula or schedule that account for changing levels of risk as you age.

Conventionally, it’s thought that as you get closer to retirement you should adjust your portfolio to be safer, and often that has been achieved via increasing the bond allocation relative to stocks. Now that we’re in possibly a long-term secular bond bear market, that’s not such a good idea. Typically when the ten-year yield is above 5%, stocks and bonds move together. So bonds don’t make your portfolio safer; they just add another asset sleeve that can go wrong.

And anyway it turns out that you actually need to be safer earlier in retirement rather than later. You must preserve capital early in retirement. Once you’ve gotten into your eighties, why not go nuts with aggressive investments, if you already have enough to last even if you make it twenty more years?

Sometimes advisors recommend a “rising equity glide path” for retirement where equity exposure starts lower or even dips at retirement and then gradually rises. This addresses sequence-of-returns risk and makes it less likely you’ll run out of money later, if there are difficult years in the stock market when you are about to retire or have just retired.

My own personal situation

In my financial forecast, I used 3% as the expected return for all three of my investment accounts (income that I am living on, traditional IRA, and Roth IRA) and I still end up with plenty of money, with my house paid off, and a large nest egg.

You might think: “3% – that’s easy! You can get that in a money market fund.” And yes you can right now, and probably for at least a couple more years as the Fed is hiking.

But the challenge is: what if I don’t put the money in something safe? Then I’m taking an entirely different possible path. What if I try to earn more than 3% and instead I see a drawdown of five, or ten, or twenty percent?

And, if I just throw my hands up and say “I’ll stay in cash” I’m losing out to inflation.

Earning yield on your savings

Moving into 2027, there’s an opportunity playing out: higher yields on fixed income. This is happening at a time when the stock market is weak. In fact, half of global stocks are in a bear market, even as broad market indexes such as the S&P 500 have held up.

Yes I’ve written recently that it may not be a good time to get into bonds. What I was thinking of then is increasing a bond allocation in a long-term portfolio, say from 80/20 stocks to bonds to 60/40, using bond ETFs. But if you have a specified time at which you plan to use some money, you can get a good return by buying bonds of that duration right now and holding them to maturity. The underlying value of your bond may go up and down as interest rates fall and rise, but you can be guaranteed a certain return (keeping in mind inflation can erode the value of that return).

So what will I do?

I’m not sure. I’m still interested in continuing my options wheeling and my tactical portfolio allocation a.k.a. structured panicking approaches. Both are suffering right now as there is basically no strength anywhere in stocks or bonds. It’s a good time to just sit tight, with my large allocation to cash and wait.


Posted

in

by